Facing domestic violence charges can be very overwhelming. In Ohio, domestic violence cases carry serious consequences, including possible jail time, fines, or a permanent criminal record. These charges often come with a lot of emotional weight and can impact a person’s family life, job, and future. People who face these charges may feel they are stuck in a very difficult situation, but there are defenses that can help protect them. Knowing what defenses are available can make a big difference in the outcome of a case. This understanding is key, as each defense offers a unique approach to challenging the evidence and arguments presented in court.
The Ohio legal system treats domestic violence cases seriously, and it is important to respond to charges carefully and with a well-thought-out defense strategy. Each case has its own details, and the best defense will depend on those specific circumstances. But several common defenses apply to many domestic violence cases in Ohio. By understanding these defenses, a person facing charges may feel better prepared for the legal process. At, Sabol & Mallory Law Firm , we are here to guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of your case.
Dan Sabol
Dan is the first attorney in Ohio to be both board certified in criminal trial law by the National Board of Trial Advocacy and be designated as a Lawyer Scientist by the American Chemical Society.
Chase Mallory
Chase Mallory is a firm founder whom has tried over 40 cases and conducted more than 100 suppression hearings. He is a founding member of the DUI Defense Lawyers Association
Meet the lawyers who make up the legal team at Sabol Mallory LLC. Read their individual bios and get to know more about their education, experience and accolades.
Learn more about our teamSelf-Defense in Domestic Violence Cases
Self-defense is one of the most common defenses used in domestic violence cases in Ohio. When a person is attacked or feels that they are in immediate danger, Ohio law allows them to protect themselves. In cases of self-defense, the accused person argues that they were not the aggressor and only acted in response to a real threat. To prove self-defense, there are certain elements that must be shown. First, the accused must prove that they truly believed they were in danger. This belief must be reasonable, meaning any reasonable person in their situation would have also felt threatened. Next, the amount of force used in defense must be equal to the threat they faced. In other words, if a person felt their life was in danger, they would be allowed to use more force to protect themselves compared to a minor threat. However, using excessive force may make it harder to argue self-defense.
Ohio law also requires that, if possible, a person should retreat or leave the situation instead of using force, unless they are in their own home. Known as the “castle doctrine,” Ohio law says that if a person is in their own home, they do not have to retreat and may defend themselves from an intruder or threat. A self-defense argument can be complex, so providing evidence like witness testimony, injuries, or even text messages that support the claim can be helpful.
Client
Testimonials
Learn what our clients have to say about the work of Sabol Mallory. If you have any questions or need legal help for a criminal charge, please reach out to us right away.
Chase Mallory is incredible. He is wonderful to work with and knows exactly what to do to help his clients. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for all you've done for me. I highly recommend hiring Chase to help fight your battles. Bless you!
- Erin R.
Dan Sabol is probably the best attorney I've ever worked with. Very professional and worked hard to get the best results possible. He will be the first person I call if I need a lawyer again. If you find yourself in a sticky situation make sure you give him a ring.
- Christopher R.
I had the pleasure of working with Dan and Chase and I am very grateful!! They did amazing work to help me on my case. They are very helpful and get back with you in a timely manner whenever I had questions for them, which was very nice and reassuring.
- Jessica H.
Defense of Others as a Justification
Similar to self-defense, defense of others can also be used as a defense in Ohio domestic violence cases. This defense applies when a person uses force to protect another person, such as a family member, friend, or even a stranger, if they believe that the other person is in immediate danger of harm. This defense also requires that the force used matches the level of threat. For instance, if a person intervenes in an argument to protect someone else, the law expects that they would not use more force than necessary to protect the other person. To be successful in using this defense, the person must show that they believed the other person was in real danger and that their actions were reasonable under the circumstances.
False Allegations and Mistaken Identity
False allegations are a frequent defense in domestic violence cases. In some situations, an accusation may come out of anger, revenge, or an attempt to gain an advantage in a divorce or child custody case. False accusations can happen, especially if there are underlying issues between the parties involved, such as disagreements about children or finances. In other cases, a person may be wrongly identified as the one who committed the act. Misunderstandings, confusion, or even simple mistakes can lead to someone being falsely accused. Proving that the accusation is false may involve presenting evidence such as messages, witness statements, or an alibi to show that the accused person could not have committed the alleged act.
Mistaken identity can also happen when an incident occurs quickly, and witnesses misidentify who was involved. This is common in situations where there are multiple people present, or where confusion and stress cloud the events. With mistaken identity cases, having proof that shows where the accused was at the time of the alleged incident can be very helpful. Video footage, receipts, or even phone data may serve as strong evidence to show that the accused was not at the scene when the incident happened.
Lack of Evidence to Support the Charges
Another defense against domestic violence charges is the lack of evidence. For the prosecution to secure a conviction, they must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused person committed the act. This means they need strong evidence that leaves no doubt in the minds of the jury or judge. If the evidence is weak, unclear, or inconsistent, it can be challenging for the prosecution to prove guilt. Lack of evidence can mean there are no witnesses to confirm the story, no physical proof of harm, or insufficient records to support the allegations. Sometimes, what seems like evidence can be questioned in court and shown to be unreliable.
For example, if the only evidence is a statement from the alleged victim, it may be difficult for the prosecution to prove the case if there are no other forms of proof to support that statement. An experienced defense attorney can challenge weak evidence and may argue that the lack of reliable proof makes it impossible for the prosecution to meet the standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Consent as a Defense
In certain cases, the defense of consent can be argued. This applies if the accused person can show that both parties involved agreed to the actions in question. While this may not apply in every case, in situations where both people were engaging in mutual behavior, such as roughhousing or a consensual physical encounter, it could be possible to argue that both parties consented to the interaction. Consent as a defense requires strong proof, often involving witness statements, messages, or other evidence that shows both people agreed to the interaction. This defense is less common, but it may work in specific situations where the court sees evidence that both individuals were willing participants.
Alibi Defense in Domestic Violence Cases
An alibi is a strong defense when an accused person was not at the scene when the alleged act happened. If the accused can prove they were somewhere else, this provides a solid argument against the charges. For example, if a person was at work, visiting a friend, or running errands when the incident supposedly occurred, they could present witnesses, receipts, or even digital records to show their location. A reliable alibi can significantly weaken the prosecution’s case because it raises reasonable doubt about the accused person’s involvement.
The Role of Mental Health in Domestic Violence Defenses
In some cases, mental health issues may be relevant to a defense. If a person has a mental health condition that affects their behavior, it may help explain actions or misunderstandings that led to the domestic violence charge. Courts consider mental health when it impacts a person’s ability to understand their actions or control their behavior. For example, conditions such as PTSD, anxiety, or bipolar disorder might play a role in how an incident unfolded. While mental health alone is not a complete defense, it can be used to provide context and may lead to a more favorable outcome, such as reduced charges or alternative sentencing options.
Facing domestic violence charges can be confusing and stressful, and the legal process can be hard to understand without help. Defending against these charges requires careful planning, understanding of Ohio’s laws, and a clear presentation of facts. Each of these defenses comes with specific requirements and must be handled with care to increase the chances of a positive outcome. If you or someone you know is facing domestic violence charges, it is essential to seek skilled legal help. Sabol & Mallory Law Firm understands how important a strong defense is and is ready to guide you through every step of your case. Reach out to Sabol & Mallory Law Firm today to discuss your defense options and take the first step toward protecting your rights.